The Sultan of East 79th Street: Surveillance and Fear Replaces Freedom!

IMAGES IN THIS POST: They are posted for parody purposes only in the exercise of the author’s First Amendment rights to free speech and freedom of the press about a public figure. 

ΕΑΝ ΠΡΟΤΙΜΑΤΕ ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΑ ΠΑΤΗΣΤΕ ΤΗ ΣΗΜΑΙΑ ΣΤΟ ΚΑΤΩ ΜΕΡΟΣ ΤΗΣ ΟΘΟΝΗΣ

The Archbishop’s move to hire a private investigator and demand his own committee’s phone records exposes a culture of secrecy, control, and distrust at the heart of the Archdiocese. Preparations are already underway for a second demonstration – this time outside 8 East 79th Street!!

By Nick Stamatakis

The latest revelation from the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America has stunned even longtime insiders. According to TNH, Archbishop Elpidophoros hired a private investigator to probe members of his own Executive Committee for an alleged leak to the press.

Attorney Elena Paraskevas-Thadani, retained by the Archbishop, sent a letter demanding that every attendee of the September 30 meeting hand over personal cell-phone records — including calls and app-based communications (WhatsApp included) — from 4 p.m. Sept. 30 through 4 p.m. Oct. 1.

The letter justified the demand by citing a “leak of Committee of Continental information.” What on earth is the Committee of Continental Information? It sounds like a Nazi Agency!!  Such a body has never been heard of in GOARCH’s structure. If it exists, who created it, under what authority, and why has it never been disclosed?

Legality in Question

Under the Electronic Communications Privacy Act and the Telephone Records and Privacy Protection Act, private investigators cannot legally obtain phone-record data without explicit consent. The investigator’s request might appear voluntary — “please provide your records” — but when it comes from the Archbishop’s office, voluntariness evaporates.

If any committee member felt pressured to comply, that undermines the validity of consent. And should anyone attempt to access carrier data without permission or a court order, it could cross into illegality.

Even the White House Doesn’t Do This

Leaks happen everywhere — in the White House, the Pentagon, and Fortune 500 boardrooms. Yet no American President has ever demanded that cabinet members surrender private call logs to hunt down a journalist’s source.

Imagine that headline: President Orders Cabinet to Hand Over Personal Phones.
It would spark national outrage — and lawsuits. If such conduct is intolerable in secular institutions, it is unthinkable in a religious one.

A Church, Not a Security Agency

The Archdiocese is supposed to guide souls, not monitor phones. For decades, faithful parishioners have pleaded for transparency and accountability — not surveillance. Instead, secrecy deepens. The Church’s moral authority depends on openness; once it begins acting like an intelligence agency, its witness collapses.

The Hidden Ledgers

This secrecy extends to finances. For years, clergy and laity have asked GOARCH to publish a complete inventory of its real-estate holdings, endowments, and investment accounts — gifts from generations of Greek Orthodox faithful.

The Archdiocese refuses.

Everyone knows these assets are substantial. Yet no one outside a small circle knows where they are, how they’re managed, or what happens when they’re liquidated. The faithful deserve to know: Where does the money go? Who benefits?

A Sultan’s Mindset in an American Church

After six years in the United States, Archbishop Elpidophoros still rules as if he commands an empire, not a congregation. The expectation of obedience, the punishment of dissent, the instinct for control — all point to a Sultan’s mentality.

In Turkey, ‘Sultan’ Erdogan imprisons journalists and jails opponents. In America, Elpidophoros mimics the pattern — silence in Astoria, silence now in the Archdiocese headquarters, silence even in his own Executive Committee.

Among those sitting on that committee are noteworthy names: John Catsimatides, Michael Psaros, Elaine Allen, and others — prominent Greek-Americans of means and influence. Will they really turn over their personal phone records to a hired detective?  The community is waiting. So far — silence.

The Larger Crisis: The Church’s greatest leak isn’t to the press — it’s the steady leak of trust.

The investigator scandal is not an isolated lapse; it’s the inevitable fruit of a leadership culture that resists sunlight. Without transparency, suspicion grows. Without humility, power corrupts. The faithful entrusted their Church with gifts, loyalty, and love — not with surveillance powers. If the Archdiocese continues down this path, it risks losing what no investigation can recover: credibility. Membership has already dropped from nearly half a million to less than 125,000!!

The faithful will not take this quietly. Across parishes, conversations are growing louder, frustration is mounting, and people are openly questioning how far this leadership can drift from the Church’s core values. The Greek-American community has always stood up for freedom, dignity, and truth—principles that belong at the heart of our faith, not on its margins.

We have learned that many are calling for a second demonstration, this time not in Astoria but in front of 8 East 79th Street! But Astoria’s unique “prototype” and Elpidophoros himself, with his “Sultanic” attitude, have set the tone: It will start with the Greek National Anthem and end with a slogan much harsher than the one shouted in Astoria: “Sultans Belong To Turkey and Not to America!”…

===========

PS.  I would be remiss not to note how prophetic yours truly was in dubbing Archbishop Elpidophoros “Elpidoktonos” — the Hope-Killer — the day after his election. It took most of the media nearly half a decade to recognize what was clear from the start: the warning signs were already there in 2019. Among numerous other facts that were betraying his true character in 2019, we knew that he (and Bartholomew) had served in the Intelligence Unit of the Turkish Armed Forces.  We also knew that in May 2018, two days after Metropolitan Nathanael was enthroned in Chicago, the Turkish Consul paid a long visit to his office. The patterns of ambition, secrecy, and disregard for accountability and the imposition of “Sultanic” culture in America were visible to anyone who looked closely. Yet, back then, most of the so-called “journalists” chose silence—or worse, derision. We still await a word of acknowledgment or even a simple expression of regret. 

October 28, 2025, n.stamatakis@aol.com   www.helleniscope.com

DISCLAIMER: The views and statements expressed in this article constitute constitutionally protected opinions of this author.

TO SUPPORT HELLENISCOPE OR BECOME A SUBSCRIBER, LINK HERE!!