source – dimokratia.gr – follow the link for the original Greek text

He Offered “Congratulations” for the Shameful Agreements Concerning Sinai and the 48 Religious Treasures

Archbishop Makarios of Australia found the ideal setting today, at the Church of Saint Demetrios, to provide a much-needed “fig leaf” for the government and the prime minister. At a time when the government’s handling of the historic Monastery of Sinai, as well as the outrageous agreement with Bulgaria concerning religious treasures, is provoking fierce reactions, the head of the Greek Orthodox community in Australia undertook to sugarcoat the bitter pill, generously providing political cover for Kyriakos Mitsotakis. Yet the identity of the person offering these indulgences undermines every attempt to legitimize the concessions, as the Archdiocese’s history is deeply troubling and the revelations grim.

His tenure in Oceania is dramatically removed from the ideal of a discreet and humble hierarch. It has been marked by an endless barrage of legal disputes and an inconceivable display of wealth that has caused deep divisions within the local Greek community. In 2020, the faithful watched in astonishment as revelations emerged about the purchase of an ultra-luxurious apartment in central Sydney, reportedly costing nearly $6.5 million. Australia’s public broadcaster, ABC, aired a report at the time linking the new residence’s extravagance to government funding received by the Basilias aged-care facilities, during a period when the pandemic was taking a devastating toll.

The most pressing issue, however, was not the millions spent on real estate but the dark corridors of the St. Basil’s aged-care home in Melbourne. It was there that perhaps the darkest chapter in the history of the Greek-Australian community was written. Revelations about the management of this facility, which operated under the Archdiocese’s direct umbrella, continue to provoke outrage to this day. The ongoing judicial investigation into the circumstances in which 50 elderly residents lost their lives—45 of them directly affected by coronavirus—has brought horrifying details to light.

While the authorities in the state of Victoria investigate the grave responsibilities of the management for the agonizing deaths of so many members of the Greek diaspora, the spiritual leader of these institutions appears in Athens as a guarantor of our national heritage.

The Archdiocese took legal action, and ABC was compelled to issue a retraction in 2021, clarifying that the Church’s official trust had transferred the property. Despite this legal vindication, the image of a hierarch residing in a property of scandalously high value amid a global crisis has never faded.

The problems, however, did not end there. In the summer of 2023, a sordid scandal erupted within the Archdiocese involving a senior archimandrite who had been serving undisturbed in parishes in Melbourne and Adelaide. It was established that the clergyman embezzled $500,000 from donations made by the faithful to fund premium subscriptions and to exchange expensive digital material through the dating app Grindr. Although he was reportedly eventually defrocked, the administration that allowed such plundering under its nose was irreparably discredited.

Instead of acting as a shepherd of unity, Mr. Makarios turned the Archdiocese into a litigation machine. He became embroiled in a continuous legal war against those who accused him of mismanaging fundraising campaigns, including those organized for the devastating Black Summer bushfires. He sued media outlets, even securing damages exceeding $300,000 against Greek-Australian journalist Alkis Morelas over publications alleging bribery. The Church’s environment descended into a toxic cycle of legal threats, extrajudicial notices, and disrepute.

This very man today transformed the pulpit into a political platform. He began with conspicuous flattery, declaring: “Since we say that we should acknowledge the good things, I too have a duty today to say a few additional good things.”

After conveying the good wishes of one million Orthodox Christians from Australia, he solemnly told the prime minister: “You have everyone’s good wishes and love, and faithful prayers for your work, which is precious and difficult.”

Getting to the heart of the matter, he portrayed the surrender of Sinai’s property and its transformation into a monastery operating under a kind of leasing arrangement as a national success.

“Because we Church people cannot judge political matters, but we can judge ecclesiastical matters, allow me to offer you my warmest congratulations for this agreement,” he declared.

He even maintained that “I glorify God that our prime minister… managed to resolve this great and longstanding outstanding issue,” thereby saving the oldest monastic institution—which “is even older than Mount Athos”—from being endangered by people “hostile toward it.”

But he did not stop there. He also attempted to whitewash the government’s submissiveness toward Bulgaria, applauding it on the grounds that “a very good beginning has been made, and certain things that are precious to us have been returned.”

The doctrine of forgetting the plunder of cultural heritage was encapsulated in his statement:

“I believe that gradually, through goodwill, courtesy, and dialogue—which is how we should conduct ourselves nowadays—everything will be accomplished, and we will be proud.”

In doing so, he effectively legitimized what is clearly a sellout.

2 COMMENTS

  1. The “Church World” We Live In

    There are no greater liars than those who claim
    that God called them into
    the ministry.”

    Fall on your knees,Makarios!

  2. Reading the above, it makes me feel lighter, because us, Greek-Americans are not the only ones suffering under the dictatorial, selfish, and unChristian rule of the celibates in the archdiocese of New York. Misery loves company.
    The Greek-Australians, who are more Greek than we are, are being abused by their shepherds, thereby estranging the younger, Australian born generation, who will abandon Orthodoxy. Australian society is already post-Christian, with church attendence in all denominations in the single digits.

    Greek-Australians have it worse than us in one respect. Our freedom of speech is more protected than theirs. For a clergy to sue a journalist for exposing their luxurious life style and take $300,000 from him is the the ultimate un-Christian action. It is treason against their “flock” and treason against scripture, which forbids secular courts from judging religious disputes. Unless of course, a crime has been committed. What true “shepherd” would harm one of their “sheep”?

    My suggestion to our brethren in Australia is to hound these false clergy by protesting, peacefully, wherever they appear with signs calling them ANAXIOI. And of course not contributing a dime towards membership. If you have a need for a house of worship, join other denominations. You have choices

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here